What is good fantasy?
Written by Jason Koop.
Last week, we took a crack at the question: Where can I find fantasy? And now that that’s done, I’d like to answer the questions: What is good fantasy? And where do I find it?
Perhaps it would help if we first defined what is “good” fantasy, exactly? Does it have to endorse good character and morals? Does the narrative’s plot have to be tight and engrossing? What about the characters? What is the most important thing?
Well, in my opinion, the answer is simply: “you.”
Yes, you. The reader. Yes, the parameters and preferences will change as you do, but that’s part of the beauty of it. There’s nothing wrong with something being utterly fantastic for a season, while another thing remains in your mind across multiple years.
So perhaps the question should be: What do I like in stories? What gets me to invest the time and energy into reading them (or having them read to me if you’re into the audiobook scene)? Well, let’s break this down into some more specific questions.
Is there a particular setting that you like? Medieval? Age of Sail? Space?
What type of characters do you like? Heroic heroes? Brooding anti-heroes? Ordinary, everyday people?
Do you prefer sprawling epics, or something shorter and maybe more laid-back?
Are there certain creatures you prefer? Animals? Aliens? Or do you prefer the more mundane humans?
This may help you define what you are more likely to enjoy, and hence narrow your search. But what if this is still not enough (or perhaps too much)?
Here are some ideas that may prove useful in finding your next favourite fantasy.
Check out book review sites like Goodreads. While their opinions likely won’t match up perfectly with yours, you might get some good ideas from fellow readers’ recommendations.
Check to see if other media (movies, TV shows, etc.) came from books. For example, you like the “How to Train Your Dragon” movies? Well, they were originally a book series.
Ditto for adaptations from other mediums INTO books. Like the Legend of Zelda video games? There’s official manga! These are almost never a 1-1 adaptation because there are things that work in one form that don’t translate to others. They can help you see stories from a different perspective.
Check out a familiar author’s bibliography. Odds are they wrote more than just what you are currently reading or have already read.
Check out publishers’ websites. If they sold one fantasy book, odds are there are a lot more.
Ask your friends for recommendations. And, if possible, ask them why they are recommending what they do. It may prove useful so you can track what kind of books they are likely to recommend you in the future, should you ask again.
There are a plethora of ways to find a fantasy story that you’ll like. The thing to remember is that there is no shame in saying “I don’t like this” and moving on until you find something that you do enjoy. Don’t underestimate the joy to be found in discovering a new favourite story.